Close-up Photography [Weekly Duel]

In Landscape/Nature by Jim Harmer60 Comments

Today is the very first camera duel, a weekly feature we're adding to ImprovePhotography.com.  This week's theme is close-up photography.

We chose close-up photography for the first Improve Photography Duel because it's something I've always struggled with.  I'm generally not a big fan of close-up or macro photography because they all look the same to me.  Once you've seen a nice flower picture… they all look the same.  It feels to me like macro photographers are so consumed with the magic of making something small look big that they forget to do anything creative with the composition or lighting.

So, we set out to try and do something different with close-up photography and get our creative juices pumping.

One quick not before we get going is that we called this the close-up duel instead of the macro duel because this isn't macro photography.  Although many photographers use “macro” to mean any type of close-up photography, true “macro” means producing a 1:1 replication of the scene.  That means that an ant in real life would be reproduced to be the size of an ant on the image sensor.  True macro photography usually requires dedicated macro lenses, which most people don't own; therefore, we chose close-up photography which is doable with nearly any lens.

Close-Up Photography Duel

Jim Here:  It's finally starting to feel like Spring in Idaho, and the flowers in my front garden started to pop up this week.  I really liked the flowers, but I DEFINITELY didn't want just a traditional “Yeah!  Look!  I made the flower look bigger!” kind of photo.   I wanted to add interesting lighting and a more dramatic mood to the photo.  So, I decided to do light painting.  I've never seen a close-up light painting, so I thought it would be fun to try.

Jim's Process: I first tried to take this picture in my front yard where the flowers were.  I went out at 11PM to shoot the flowers so that I could fully control the lighting without fighting the sun (and yes, my neighbors probably think I'm a nutcase).  However, when I went outside at night to do the shoot, the flowers had closed up for the night.  So, the next morning I dug up the flower and brought it to the studio in a box (this is when Dustin started thinking I was a nutcase).  Having the flower inside made the process much easier.

Under the flower, the ground turned a bit yellow due to the light reflecting off the yellow/green stem of the flower.  I was going to get rid of that color cast in Photoshop, but in the end I decided that I kind of like the warm glow.  I showed the photo to a few people to get some feedback, and they were 50/50 on whether or not to get rid of the color cast on the dirt.

The camera was on a tripod (obviously), and I used an inexpensive Stylus Streamlight flashlight to paint the light on the flower during the exposure.  If you don't have a flashlight like that, you could use the LED flash on your smartphone and get the exact same result.  I recorded a video of how I made this photo and I'll release it on our Youtube channel in the coming weeks.

Jim's Metadata:

Shutter speed: 30 seconds, Aperture: f/16, ISO 100.

Camera: Nikon D800, Lens: Nikkor 24-70mm f/2.8.

Lighting: Stylus Streamlight flashlight

Light painting technique in photography used on a close-up photo of a flower

Jim's entry into the duel.

 

Dustin Here: Allow me to introduce you to my photo for this week's Photo Duel!! I had such a blast doing macro photos for this duel that it was really hard to pick just one.

Dustin's Process: I love the vibrant colors in a peacock feather – but I knew it needed more than just a great angle. That's when I grabbed my medicine dropper and carefully placed water drops on it. The next challenge was to get the right amount of side lighting to bring out the texture in the feather, but enough light to expose everything the way I wanted it. With the use of my flashbender, I was able to wrap it around the lens and the feather to get the lighting that you see here.

Once I had the shot that I was in love with, I did basic edits in CameraRaw (such as: Exposure, contrast, saturation, etc) and then used Nik Software Color Efex Pro to give it a bit of a glow. That's it.

Dustin's Metadata:

Shutter speed: 1/160, Aperture: f/16, ISO 200

Camera: Canon 6D, Lens: Canon 24-105mm lens with Macro Extension Tubes

Lighting: YN-560 Speedlight with Flashbender light modifier

Water Dropped Peacock Feather - By Dustin Olsen

Water Dropped Peacock Feather – By Dustin Olsen

 

Let the Voting Begin!

Please note that you do NOT have to share this to your Facebook page or Twitter feed in order to vote.  It just gives you that as an option after you've clicked your vote.


About the Author

Jim Harmer

Facebook Twitter Google+

Jim Harmer is the founder of Improve Photography, and host of the popular Improve Photography Podcast. More than a million photographers follow him on social media, and he has been listed at #35 in rankings of the most popular photographers in the world. He blogs about how to start an internet business on IncomeSchool.com..

Comments

  1. Hey guys – great challenge. I love the idea of light painting Jim used and I’ve got to try it out. Dustin’s photo gets my vote, although, it may not be all that original.

  2. I think they are both great. I like them both from different reasons. I find this challenge fascinating.

  3. Dustin wins for me this week. I prefer the composition and it simply interests me more…sorry Jim! I like the weekly duel…have you (or are you) considering opening it up to your fans too – seems like a good way to get us off our butts to shoot!
    All the best
    Rich

  4. Author

    @Rich – You’re totally wrong about your vote :-), but yes, we’re planning to open this up to fans soon.

    We just want to do a week or two first so people can see how we do it.

  5. Hi, Fun idea. I like the creativity of Dustin’s feather photo but I also like the simple creative technique of Jim’s . I vote for Jim !!

  6. I really like the flower and the creativity behind it. Great job guys!

  7. Both are great. Strong colors and great textures. I would like to see the flower shot closer. I think it would have more impact like the feather does. I would hang both on my wall. It would be interesting to see each of you given the same subject and see what you do with it.

  8. Jim – I’d have to agree with those folks that said “Remove the yellow cast” I would have voted for yours if it weren’t for that. Love light painting!

  9. Not going to choose, they’re both neat in their own ways. Tie for me. Love the challenge and your willingness to share how the shot was captured! Thanks

  10. I love the idea! I also love and appreciate the fact that you guys are sharing your settings and how to for the photos! Thanks much!

  11. Jim, I’ve been taking a lighting class at a local university and wanted to share something I learned in one of my classes. If you would have wanted to leave the flower in the dirt and take the photo during the day, using your light as the main source of light, set your ISO at 200, shutter speed at 200 and aperture at 5.6. When you take a test shot without your light, almost everything will be dark. Then shine your light source on your subject and take your picture. I had a lot of fun with that project and just wanted to pass along what I learned. The way you did your photo looks great too!

  12. Author

    @Ginni – Thank you for sharing that. Good tip. In this situation, it didn’t work for me because I didn’t have a light bright enough to overpower the sun. I could have used a flash to overpower the sun, but that would be too large for such a tiny flower.

  13. Personally, I think Jim nailed it. Furthermore the req. was “close up” NOT “EXTREME Close up”. The yellow highlight on the ground, very nice touch creating a surreal image. Looking forward to the amateur duels. I think it’s a grand idea. Simple suggestion, all those interested could be randomly paired off and we vote on each others’ submissions. Should be fun and interactive. Looking forward to it!

  14. Not voting either as I too like them both equally well and love the creative thought and effort of put into them both.

  15. I voted for Dustin. I actually loved Jim’s flower for the flower, but it needed cropping or digital cleanup to make the flower really pop. The grass in the background, especially on the right, is very distracting.

  16. I prefer Jims photo but in my eyes it doesn’t fit the topic of close-up very well.
    Just boring and always the same, sorry Dustin. You nailed the topic but the pic isn’t worth winning a duel :-/
    I love the weekly duel idea! 🙂

    (This comment has been edited to meet the Improve Photography comment guidelines)

Leave a Comment