BEST BATTERIES FOR YOUR SPEEDLIGHTS: A SHOWDOWN

Flash Photography today is an area within Photography that has never been easier to enter. With a vast array of flashes, from top brands that cost hundreds of dollars to Chinese knockoffs that are very inexpensive, the choices are great to say the very least.

 

What I wanted to test for this article is which rechargeable batteries performed the very best in a speedlight flash.  There are even more batteries choices available to us than there are speedlights brands. How do we know what is best? What will provide the best performance? The best cost? Or both!?!

In Short, Here's the Result of My Testing
The short answer to the best battery for speedlights is that the Duracell Rechargeable 2500 mAh (click to buy on Amazon) was the best performing battery in our tests. It delivered 228 pops of a flash on full power with very fast recycle times. The Eneloop Pro batteries (click to buy on Amazon) performed admirably and were close enough to the Duracell batteries that there was little difference between the two. While the Eneloop PRO batteries were amazing, the regular Eneloops did not perform well.

Battery Types

In this test we focused mainly on the AA nickel–metal hydride (Ni Mh) batteries along with the regular Alkaline batteries that we all are familiar with.  We included a set of Duracell Quantum AA batteries to represent the Alkaline side. These batteries are certainly less expensive than the rechargeable Ni Mh batteries in terms of initial cost, but in the long run, the cost is much more. What about performance? Are the Alkaline batteries better than the rechargeable batteries when it comes down to actual shooting? Alkaline batteries are rated at 1.5 volts and the Ni Mh batteries are only 1.2 volts. They must be better – right?  NOT so fast!

Testing Setup

The simple setup used for testing.

To assure authentic and fair results, the same flash was used to test every set of batteries. The test flash in this experiment was the inexpensive but very capable YN-560 iii from Yongnuo. Many readers and podcast listeners of the ImprovePhotography network know that these are the chosen flash heads for many of the hosts and a whole slew of fans as well. At the recent ImprovePhotography Retreat in Phoenix, AZ, (March 9-11, 2017) it became quickly apparent that this was the overwhelming choice of most everyone there!

The test camera was a Nikon D3200 (could have been anything) placed on a tripod and connected to an Intervalometer. The intervalometer was set to fire up to 300 shots at full 1/1 power with a 30 second delay between each shot. This would avoid thermal overload which would negate any results that were being recorded. When shooting at full power continuously, the batteries and flash can become EXTREMELY hot – so hot that you cannot touch the batteries for long! I wanted to make sure the flash also was not burned out as well.

Using this method allowed me to record flash recycle times throughout the duration of the testing and also to gather information on just how many total flashes were possible from a set of the batteries when fully charged. Testing to failure was the goal and it worked very well.

Batteries Tested

The batteries used were as follows:

  • AmazonBasics AA High-Capacity Rechargeable Batteries (2400mAh)
  • AmazonBasics AA Rechargeable Batteries (1900mAh)
  • The Newest version of the Eneloop Panasonic AA NiMH Batteries (1900mAh)
  • Panasonic BK-3HCCA4BA Eneloop Pro AA High Capacity Ni-MH Batteries (2500mAh)
  • Duracell High-Capacity Rechargeable Batteries (2500mAh)
  • Duracell Quantum Alkaline Batteries (1.5v)

Like any other product on the market, there have been some pretty advanced scientific break thru moments that have occurred over the past few years in the rechargeable battery world. For many years, rechargeable batteries had a bad reputation because they weren't very powerful and they lost their charge very quickly. As a matter of fact, just within the last five years there have been some great strides made in the rechargeable battery world. We will get to that and more below but let's get to the testing!

Testing Methodology

Using the intervalometer to trigger the flash in a very mechanical, exacting way, I used an electronic stopwatch to record the recycle times. This was very tedious indeed but I can assure you I sampled each shot around the predetermined intervals (10, 20, 50th, etc) to make sure I was getting very specific results. The recycle time is of utmost importance because when shooting an event where your flash speed is critical, we cannot be standing and waiting for our flashes to be ready for that next shot. We need speed! It is very easy to toss the retired batteries into a bag and pop new ones in but to wait every shot with seconds between each one is just not acceptable.

The left side is the recycle time in seconds. The bottom is the flash count. Notice how the Ni Mh batteries actually work better once they warm up and stay very steady throughout their shooting task.

#6 – Duracell Quantum (Alkaline Battery 1.5v)

Number of Full Power Flash Pops: 137

Recycle Time: Horrible

DURACELL Quantum Alkaline Batteries by far were the worst of the group. Alkaline batteries have 1.5 volts versus the lesser 1.2 volts that the Ni Mh batteries have. You may wonder how these batteries with lesser power not only beat their Alkaline cousins but that they work at all in devices that call for FOUR 1.5v batteries.

The extreme heat got to these Alkaline batteries as you can see here!

The truth of it is most modern devices will work with the Ni Mh batteries despite the lower voltage. Infact, about 95% of all products today accept Ni Mh batteries in place of the Alkaline type.

The Quantum Recycyle Time went up – and stayed up as the testing went on. If that weren't bad enough, they also expired much sooner that the rechargeable types tested. Toward the end of their testing, the recycle times were extremely slow and pretty much not useable in most shooting situations.

#5 – Amazon Basics 1900mAh (1.2v)

Number of Full Power Flash Pops: 157

Recycle Time: Fair

Next up on the list were the Amazon Basics batteries.  They didn't perform particularly well in terms of recycle time or total number of flash pops, but they are also the cheapest batteries we tested.

Although these batteries did get 16 more flash pops than the Panasonic Eneloop batteries, they can't be charged as many times and thus ranked lower in my test.

These are a good value and can be purchased HERE. They are rated at 1900mAh and 1,000 recycle charges.

#4 – Panasonic Eneloop – NEW Edition 1900mAh (1.2v)

Number of Full Power Flash Pops: 141

Recycle Time: Fair

These New Eneloop batteries (not the pro version) have with them an impressive claim that they can be used and recharged an impressive 2,100 times before the battery stops holding a charge. When you add that up along with their great performance, they are an outstanding value.

The amount of charges these batteries (Any Ni Mh battery) can accept or be given is greatly dependent on how the batteries are cared for – meaning how they are charged. More on that below… To purchase these new batteries, click HERE!

#3 – Amazon Basic High Capacity 2400mAh (1.2v)

Number of Full Power Flash Pops: 213

Recycle Time: Good

A step up from the 1900mAh “Basic” batteries are these – the 2400mAh High Capacity type. The price of the Amazon Basic Standard per 4 pack is $8.99 at the time of this writing and $10.78 for the High Capacity version listed here at #3. It is important to remember when trying to decide on value which is best for you.

The lower capacity batteries can accept MANY more charges than the higher performance types. Since the lower capacity batteries here also fared very well in overall performance, it would not be a bad idea at all to make them your go to batteries. These HIGH CAPACITY AMAZON BASIC batteries can be purchased HERE!

#2 – Eneloop Pro 2550mAh

Eneloop Pro – The long Standing favorite among many photographers. Shown here with included charger.

Number of Full Power Flash Pops: 218

Recycle Time: Excellent

For years now the Eneloop XX batteries were considered the very best – and for good reason!! They are now called “Eneloop Pro” and they come in a 2550mAh capacity. These batteries were the first I tested in this test to fire over 200 shots of the flash at full 1/1 power on a single charge and I thought they would be the winner–until I tested the Duracell.

The final results were so very close that you could easily choose these batteries and be more than fine. They have a very smooth design and they seemed to be the coolest to the touch of the bunch.

However, the Eneloops did not quite get as many flash pops as the Duracell, and they cost quite a bit more.  You can buy these Eneloop Batteries on Amazon.

WINNER – Duracell Rechargeable 2500mAh

Number of flash pops: 228

Recycle time: A+

The top dog in this competition was the very plain packaged Duracell Rechargeable 2500mAh Battery (Click to buy on Amazon).

Straight forward packaging and made to work – Duracell has a winner here!

It was extremely steady throughout the entire shootout from the very first frames right up until the bitter end where, like all the other batteries tested, it finally was put to sleep by the power hungry Speed Light. The remarkable thing about this battery is how it performed right up until that very last flash. I had the audible alert on the YN560 iii so I would be alerted when the ending was near because you can hear the recycle begin to take a little longer than the previous shots.

It went from shooting pretty much normally right to being expired and out of juice. It took a whopping 228 SHOTS AT FULL POWER to kill these super cells!!

That is the really neat thing about the Ni Mh batteries. They pretty much have an on off switch; they are either working or they aren't unlike conventional alkaline batteries.

More on Ni Mh Batteries

Ni Mh batteries are the CLEAR choice for high drain devices and a Speed Light is the epitome of just that. Alkaline batteries suffer from High Internal Resistance and this makes them a poor choice for this use case scenario.

The best part about the rechargeable Ni Mh batteries is how even they stay in terms of power output right through until they are depleted of their power.  Even with a flashlight,  conventional alkaline batteries will reduce in power output and you will see this as the light becomes more dim with use. Nh Mh batteries? They will work and work and then die – quickly. It is why you can fire off 150 full power blasts of light from a speed light and see virtually no change in recycle time but at 160 the batteries will be completely drained. This is good because when they are tired, you know it AND YOU REPLACE THEM!

HEAT

All of these batteries became VERY hot while performing these tests. The Alkaline Duracell's became so hot that the label on the battery became blistered and cracked. The others were extremely hot to the touch and I would suggest NOT touching them after excessive use.

New Technology in Ni Mh Batteries Today

For many years, rechargeable batteries got a bad rap from many users because their power output seemed to be very inconsistent. This thinking wasn't without reason. Generally speaking, Ni Mh batteries would lose 20-30% of their power after just 24 hours of lying dormant and unused in a drawer. Each consecutive day would drain these batteries even more. That has all changed.

L.S.D. – Low Self Discharge

This Chart found over on Amazon shows just how efficient LSD batteries can be!

Technology progresses in all facets of life today and batteries are not immune to these advancements! Low Self Discharge batteries are exactly what you would think them to be – batteries with low self discharge!! Some of the batteries tested here claim they will hold up to 85% of their total charge even after being stored in a drawer for a whole year!! Temperature is a big factor here and if stored, making sure they are kept at around room temperature is a very good practice.

THE MOST IMPORTANT THING

It doesn't matter what recycleble battery you are using if you are using a poorly made and designed charger. There are many “QUICK” charges on the market. Avoid them at all costs. They will ruin your batteries – plain and simple! A slow, constant and controlled charge is what works best. This has to be done by a capable charger. The EBL Charger pictured below is a great example of a very good charger that incorporates 5 different levels of protection for your batteries. Check it out HERE!

A super great charger at a great price. Save yourself money and save the planet by using rechargeable batteries!

 

 

 

Comments

  1. Thanks for the rundown. Great info here. Question – Can we use the EBL charger with any of the Ni Mh batteries? Or do we need to use that charger that came with that brand? I currently have the white Enelope and some Energizer rechargables. Wondering if these plus the Duracell’s you recommend can use the EBL charger.

    1. I don’t think it’d make a difference. It’s just a trickle charger with smart functionality to refresh batteries, etc.

  2. Author

    Jim is correct. I’ve charged many different types of batteries with this charger. It is an outstanding value and a must have piece of equipment if you use portable flash speedlights.

    1. Author

      For applications like flash, the Ni Mh batteries are the better choice. Every battery type has its own pros and cons but in this case, you can’t beat the Ni Mh batteries 🙂 Thanks for reading

  3. Do you know how these would compare to the single use energizer lithium ion batteries?

  4. Thanks for doing this test! I don’t suppose you could make a table showing the best recycle time and the total number of flash pops for each. I’m having a hard time reading the graph.

  5. Thank you! I need to buy batteries and now I know which ones to get.

    1. The way Ni Mh batteries work is that the lower the capacity, the more they are able to engineer them to get more life in terms of charge cycles. Other manufactures put fairly specific numbers but when you see the 2700+ models, it’s a very vague “hundreds” of times. Is that 200? 300? 900? They don’t say for a reason.

      This is why the Eneloop batteries that just came out are a fantastic buy. With a 2,100 cycle claim, they can recharge many more times that ones with larger capacity.

Leave a Comment